Tesla Stock Drops 33% YTD, But Is TSLA a Buy Now?

An image of a Tesla humanoid robot in front of the company logo Around the World Photos via Shutterstock

Tesla (TSLA) stock has plummeted by more than 33% year-to-date, raising questions about whether this decline presents a buying opportunity or signals deeper trouble for the electric vehicle (EV) giant. This significant drop comes amid a series of challenges for the company, including disappointing delivery figures in key markets like China and Europe and CEO Elon Musk's controversial political endeavors.

A Worrying Slowdown in China and Europe

Tesla’s struggles in China have been a significant concern. In February, the company saw its China-made wholesale deliveries plummet to just 30,688 vehicles—a steep 49.2% drop from last year, according to data from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA), as reported by Reuters. This sharp decline signals potential challenges in Tesla’s ability to maintain its foothold in the world’s largest EV market.

Europe isn’t faring much better. Germany, one of Tesla’s key markets, saw an alarming 76% year-over-year decline in vehicle registrations last month, Bloomberg reported.  Meanwhile, overall EV sales in the country surged by 31%, indicating that Tesla’s struggles aren’t due to waning demand for electric cars but rather shifting consumer preferences away from its offerings. In the first two months of 2025, Tesla’s sales in Germany are down a staggering 71% compared to 2024 levels.

There are several possible explanations for this downturn. Some of it could be attributed to production pauses as Tesla prepares to roll out the latest Model Y. However, speculation is growing that Elon Musk’s controversial political statements may be dampening consumer sentiment. At the same time, competitive pressures, especially in China, are intensifying, with domestic automakers such as BYD (BYDDY) continuing to gain market share.

www.barchart.com

Profit Margins Under Pressure

Tesla’s aggressive price cuts to stay competitive have put a strain on its profit margins. The company has lowered the average selling price of its vehicles, which has led to tighter automotive margins. While price reductions may help boost demand in the short term, they also impact profitability.

Despite these challenges, Tesla remains committed to cost optimization. The company has managed to bring its cost per vehicle down to below $35,000 through efficiencies in raw material sourcing and manufacturing. These efforts could mitigate margin pressures and keep Tesla competitive in an increasingly crowded EV market.

Long-Term Growth Drivers: AI, Robotics, and Autonomous Vehicles

While Tesla’s short-term outlook is uncertain, the company is betting on the future with massive investments in artificial intelligence (AI), robotics, and autonomous driving technology.

A key area of focus is Full Self-Driving (FSD) technology, which represents a massive long-term growth opportunity. Tesla is set on launching supervised FSD in European and Chinese markets by 2025, paving the way for a fully autonomous, unsupervised driving experience. If successful, this could give Tesla a lead in the race toward autonomous mobility, an industry poised for exponential expansion.

Another exciting development is Tesla’s Robotaxi service, which is expected to launch in select U.S. markets later this year. If successful, this could open up a new revenue stream and solidify Tesla’s position as a leader in autonomous mobility.

Tesla is also pushing boundaries in robotics with its Optimus humanoid robot project. The company expects to deliver these robots to businesses by the second half of 2026. If Optimus proves to be a success, it could open up another lucrative market for Tesla and support its long-term growth.

Expanding Energy Storage and Upcoming Product Launches

Tesla’s energy storage business is also gaining momentum. In Q4 2024, deployments reached an all-time high, with strong demand for Megapack and Powerwall systems. The company is working to ramp up production with its new Megafactory in Shanghai, set to go online in early 2025. Tesla expects at least 50% growth in energy storage deployments this year, providing an additional boost to its bottom line.

On the vehicle front, Tesla plans to introduce several new models throughout 2025, including a more affordable EV in the first half of the year. If successful, this could help Tesla regain lost market share and drive higher sales volumes.

Is Tesla a Buy Now?

Wall Street remains divided on Tesla’s outlook, with analysts largely taking a “Hold” stance. The company faces near-term challenges, including declining sales, rising competition, and profitability concerns. However, its long-term growth prospects in AI, autonomous driving, robotics, and energy storage remain strong.

www.barchart.com

For investors who can tolerate short-term volatility and have a long-term horizon, Tesla’s recent dip could represent a buying opportunity. The stock’s decline may be temporary, and the company’s future innovations could drive significant value over the next several years.


On the date of publication, Sneha Nahata did not have (either directly or indirectly) positions in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.